Monday, 19 March 2012

A Trip to the Hoover Dam: Go US!


“…yeah, they translated “pre-school” as ‘kindergarten.’ ”

“Well that’s normal; in Germany they start school at 4. I actually went to kindergarten in Germany.”

“Oh yeah, how was that?”

“A lot different. Much more about learning critical thinking and concepts. Not like the rote memorization with flashcards in America.”

“We actually do a lot of that where I work at the preschool for Google employees. It’s much more focused on building critical thinking and socio-emotional skills. Like, instead of teaching them the alphabet we give the kids cameras and have them take lots of pictures of things they’re interested and then we teach them about the things they want to learn about. So maybe they haven’t memorized what shapes the letters of the alphabet look like, but they can tell you about the parts of a car and why they’re there. And we put their pictures on the wall with quotes so that they’re invested in the words they learn. Like the other day we were working making things out of paper and one of my students said, ‘I love paper! There are so many things you can make out of paper. I’d like to make a costume out of paper.” So I wrote that down and made it the caption of his paper project. And we do a lot of socio-emotional skills, like mediating and helping them learn how to settle disputes. They’ll pick up the alphabet at some point, but these are skills they’ll need for the rest of their lives that other teachers might not take the time to teach. And honestly my students teach me. Like I have one student who’s really into space and he’s always talking about the Sombrero Galaxy or how a rocket ship is different from a space shuttle—”

“The Sombrero Galaxy?”

“I know, I had to Wikipedia it. But that’s his area of expertise, and he knows more than me on his area of expertise, even if I know more about every other subject. You know, teachers always are thrilled when the administration gives them more liberties, they always feel like they finally have the flexibility to really teach, but why don’t they give that liberty to the students? Help the students learn what they’re interested in instead of forcing a curriculum on them. A lot of teachers say they learn more from their students than their students learn from them, but that’s always outside of the classroom, how many actually apply that in the classroom? And, granted, it's difficult to be a teacher and figure out how to best suit your students’ needs, but that's no reason not to. My only concern is that once my students leave, they’re stuck in a regular school. I talked to the parents of a former student who told me their son’s 1st grade teacher assigned a family portrait assignment and their son drew his family driving in a car on a highway and his teacher told him he was wrong, that his family should’ve been sitting in a garden.”

By now we’re pulling up to the empty parking lot. I remember as he read aloud that afternoon: “The Hoover dam controls the Colorado River and provides electricity and water to nearly 20 million people…for the dam to be built the river had to be inverted. The cooling process of the concrete was sped by pumping ice cold water through pipes in the dam. It’s the largest singly poured concrete structure in the world.”

 Night has already fallen. A shock of frigid wind claws at our coats as we step from the car. We shuffle under the stale cast of yellow streetlamps. Black water licks the jagged cliffs, the only sign of life an occasional yellow glint on a wave. To the right, a powerful river, greater than most lakes I know. To the left, a gash, a wasteland, a stark nothing. Lean over the edge and behold the splendor of America’s great concrete cathedral: not a seam, such perfect conformity.

5 comments:

  1. I can't help but wonder... "traditional" schooling HAS created great thinkers... so... I mean is allowing children to learn about whatever they want going to make them better thinkers? Would the odds really change?

    Or might it make them entitled ("What do you mean I have to read Great Expecations! I don't waaaant to! I only want to learn about spaceships!")? Where is the line between discipline and freedom?

    ReplyDelete
  2. That's a really good point. Perhaps there are certain people whose dispositions fit perfectly within the traditional school system, and they're the ones who thrive. I've heard one argument that traditional schooling is biased against black boys, hence why they statistically don't perform as well.

    The teacher I'm working with now told me he feels that with the advent of the internet it really doesn't matter what you're learning anymore as much as that you're learning how to learn and adapt and think.

    But on the other hand I'm glad they made me read Great Expectations.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think one of the concerns I have as an educator is that so many feel that there is a line between discipline and freedom. As if the two compete with each other, rather than realizing you can have both. Is it not possible for a child to have discipline in learning, if he is able to focus primarily on his own interests? Of course. If I give a child flexibility in their learning, does it mean I can never select the objective or content the child will learn about? Of course not. To give a child flexibility or say in their curriculum, does not say they have total control. As I said earlier, when administrators give teachers flexibility the teachers love it, but that does not mean the teachers control every aspect of their job, what to teach, when to work, when to take vacations, when they get paid. You give that teacher framework, foundations, expectations, freedom, and respect that they can be disciplined enough to accomplish all expectations. Ray McNaulty, the President of International Center for Leadership in Education, pointed out that what got us to where we are in education will not get us where we need to be in the future. It's not a question of whether traditional schooling, or the current styles of education has produced great thinkers, it is a question of whether current styles will get us where we want/need to be. Even a superficial look a the shortcomings of education many of our kids are receiving will show there is a need for change. Ken Wesson points out that no high achieving nation spends as much time, money, or organized efforts on standardized testing as we do. The ironic thing being we use 'test-and-they-will-more" strategies, which have not proven successful anywhere, to catch up to the leading nations, even though those nations do not use such a strategy. So should kids have to read Great Expectations? Sure, why not. However, they should be allowed to read and respond in a way that is thought-provoking and meaningful. The sad fact is Cliffs Notes make millions of dollars knowing they can give enough information for school kids to pass the assessments, without ever having to read, let alone truly try to comprehend the message of the novel. I would not advocate for the removal of discipline, great works of literature, or teacher control/direction. However, I do question if our current educational systems cultivate lifelong and meaningful learning for all of our students.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That's a really good point, Michael, I guess I shouldn't have assumed that discipline and freedom are mutually exclusive. Your comment makes me wonder, what is the role of education? (Because people could--and I'm certain have--written novels about this question, I'll limit it to "practical" use). Does every child need to be able to analyze literature when not all of them will need those skills in their future jobs? While I truly believe that critical thinking can be applied to any profession, I have to wonder if that's something that should be taught or personally developed.

    (This is, of course, using a very calloused view that the role of education lies in producing an effective workforce.)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well said all around. I can't think of any jobs outside of academia that involve analyzing literature. But if critical thinking is something necessary for any profession why wouldn't it be a top priority for school curriculum? Why leave to chance something so essential?

    ReplyDelete